Going into this season people had their doubts about the Knicks. Some people said Amare’ and Melo won’t be able to work together, while others said they lack leadership, size, consistency and defensive players. During the offseason the Knicks focused on those principles. The Knicks brought in Rasheed Wallace, Jason Kidd, Kurt Thomas, Marcus Camby, Raymond Felton, Ronnie Brewer and Pablo Prigioni. During that time frame they guys like Jeremy Lin and Landry Fields go. By making those moves the Knicks added leadership, size, consistency, awareness and defensive minded players.
While they were adding players to help make the roster go, their four best players were doing things to get better on their own. Amare’ started working on his post game with Hakeem Olajuwon. By adding a legit post game to his arsenal he was suppose to help the Knicks climb the rankings more. Iman Shumpert, the best wing defender they had last season, was recovering from his acl injury so in a way he was getting better. Carmelo Anthony and Tyson Chandler got better by playing for Team USA during the Olympics. By participating in that their games expanded tremendously.
So by adding all of those elements we presumably have a nice powerhouse in the making. A roster that features Melo, Kidd, Wallace, Shumpert, Stoudamire, Camby, Felton, White, Brewer, ( until he got traded), Prigioni, Copeland, Smith, Novak and Chandler shouldn’t have any problem in dethroning the Heat as the East’s Beast, right? No, that assumption is wrong. By fast forwarding the season to where we are now the Knicks season has been injury riddled and filled with inconsistency.
At the beginning of the season they were playing mind boggling D and sharp shooting the 3, as well as moving the ball around to perfection. During that brief span they had two blowout victories over the Heat. The first victory was an emotional game. During that time the New York area was dealing with Hurricane Sandy which dealt a powerful blow to the nation’s most populated city. Before the game Heat players talked about how they shouldn’t be playing and how they didn’t want to play; the end result being a blowout victory for the Knicks. The second game against the Heat they played and won without Melo, but in the same breath Miami has a tendency to get bored and slack off when they’re playing a team that’s missing their best player. So realistically the Knicks haven’t played the Miami Heat. During the first part of the season the Knicks were missing Amare’ and Shumpert. But before they came back Rasheed Wallace and Marcus Camby went down. Jason Kidd also missed some games here and there and so did Carmelo Anthony. Once Amare’ came back Raymond Felton got hurt and the trend continues. Eventually they signed K-Mart to help out with their injury woes and nothing more.
At the end of games the Knicks have a tendency to stand around and watch Melo go to work with no help. Every so often Melo might pass the ball to J.R. Smith and let him go to work but not much. During the beginning portion of the season they moved the ball around a lot in the 4th quarter which helped them win games. And now that they’re relying on hero ball, something Melo does extremely well, the L’s have started to pile up. Despite all of the on going problems they’re dealing with they have a good record against the top 8 teams in the East, 9-8. OK I lied, that record is very pedestrian. (Keep in mind they lost 91 to 125 against the Pacers in one the recent games.) When playing against the top 8 teams in the West they currently hold a 4-4 record. Overall they’re slightly above average but nothing more. And as of right now the Chicago Bulls, even without D.Rose, the Miami Heat and the Indiana Pacers are all better than New York. In a playoff series I don’t think New York can hang with any of them, because New York struggles with tough, physical, defensive minded teams. And a case can be made that Boston poses a bigger threat to any of those three than New York does. With all jokes aside, Carmelo Anthony and the New York Knicks are no more than 2nd round and out playoff team.