Joe Flacco the Elite???????

Superbowl Mvp,record for most touchdowns thrown in playoffs history, 11-0 touchdown interception ratio in four playoff games with a Superbowl ring to cap it off. That’s everything Joe Flacco accomplished during this years playoffs; not to overlook the fact he out played both Tom Brady and Peyton Manning en route to accomplishing these feats. After that spectacular run one question must be answered; Is Joe Flacco ELITE? An elite quarterback does great things in both the regular season and postseason. Tom Brady, Drew Brees, Peyton Manning, Ben Rothlisberger and Aaron Rodgers are all elite quarterbacks because of that. You can’t just grade a quarterback on postseason play you have to look at everything. Looking at stats from last season Joe Flacco had 3,610 yards passing with 20tds and 12 picks, completing 57.6% of his passes finishing with a QBR of 59.7 (Total Rating 80.9). This season he had 3,817 passing yards with 22tds and 10 picks, completing 59.7% of his passes finishing with a QBR of 46.8 ( Total Rating 87.7). Now lets take a look at the elite quarterbacks’stats along with 6 others during this two year span.

                 THE ELITE
Tom Brady 2011: 5,235 passing yards 39tds 12 picks 65.6% passes completed. QBR 72.7 (Total Rating 105.6)
This Season: 4,827 passing yards 34tds 8 picks 63% passes completed 77.1 QBR and (98.7 TR)

Peyton Manning 2010 (didn’t play in 2011) : 4,700 yards passing 33tds 17 picks 66.3% passes completed 68.6 QBR (TR 91.9)
This Season: 4,659 passing yards 37tds 11 picks 68.6% passes completed QBR 84.1 (TR 105.8)

Drew Brees 2011: 5,476 passing yards 46tds 14 picks completed 71.2% of passes QBR 84 (TR 110.6)
This Season: 5,177 yards passing 43tds 19 picks 63% passes completed QBR 67.9 (TR 96.3)

Aaron Rogers 2011: 4,643 passing yards 45tds 6 picks 68.3% passes completed QBR 86.2 (TR 122.5)
This Season: 4,295 passing yards 39tds 8 picks 67.2 passes completed QBR 72.5 (TR 108)

Ben Rothlisberger 2011: 4,077 passing yards 21tds 14 picks 63.2% passes completed QBR 63.6 (TR 90.1)
This Season: 3,265 yards passing 26tds 8 picks 63.3% passes completed QBR 62.8 (TR 97.0)

Each of those quarterbacks won a SuperBowl or two and shows greatness throughout the season and postseason. It’s not an “I’ll show up for one part,” type of thing for them. They’re consistently consistent with everything they do. Regular season or playoffs they show up unlike the other QBs.

               The 2nd Tier

Matt Ryan 2011: 4,177 yards passing 29tds  12 picks 61.3% passes completed 69.1 QBR (TR 92.2)
This Season: 4,719 passing yards 32tds 14 picks 68.6% passes completed 74.5 QBR (TR 99.1)

Matthew Stafford 2011: 5,038 passing yards 41tds 16 picks 63.5% passes completed QBR 65.5 (TR 97.2)
This Season: 4,967 passing yards 20tds 17 picks 59.8% passes completed QBR 58.9 (TR 79.8)

Jay Cutler 2011 (injured*) : 2,319 yards passing 13tds 7 picks 58% passes completed QBR 59.8 (TR 85.7)
This Season: 3,033 passing yards 19tds 14 picks 58.8% passes completed QBR 51.9 (TR 81.3)

Matt Schaub 2011 (injured) : 2,479 passing yards 15tds 6 picks 61% completed QBR 67.5 (TR 96.8)
This Season: 4,008 passing yards 22tds 12 picks 64.3% passes completed QBR 62.6 (TR 90.7)

Tony Romo 2011: 4,184 passing yards 31tds 10 picks 66.3% passes completed 71.4 QBR (TR 102.5)
This Season: 4,903 passing yards 28tds 19 picks 65.6% passes completed QBR 62.7 (TR 90.5)

Eli Manning 2011: 4,933 passing yards 29tds 16 picks 61% passes completed QBR 59.4 (TR 92.9)
This Season: 3,948 passing yards 26tds 15 picks 59.9% passes completed QBR 67.4 (TR 87.2)

After viewing those stats does Flacco really belong in the elite category? How many of those 2nd tier quarterbacks is he better than? The answers are no and not many. There are plenty of QBs who led their respective teams to SuperBowl titles who weren’t elite. ( Example Eli Manning both years and Big Ben 1st year.) The playoffs help define your career but doesn’t nec essarily make it. If Flacco comes back next season stellar and playing out of his mind then maybe just maybe he can be considered Elite. But as if right now he’s not.

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Joe Flacco the Elite???????”

  1. Pingback: Homepage
  2. We absolutely love your blog and find most of your post’s to be just what I’m looking
    for. Do you offer guest writers to write content in your case?
    I wouldn’t mind composing a post or elaborating on many of the subjects you write in relation to here. Again, awesome website!

Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s